Get faster · Upwind

True wind vs apparent wind, and why your telltales move

The wind you feel on a moving boat isn't the wind that's blowing. What apparent wind is, how puffs and lulls move it, and what it means for telltales, trim, steering and when to tack.

Module 3 · Going upwind · Lesson 6 of 29 in the racing course

We make Sail Tactician, one of the apps in this guide, so we have a stake in the answer. We don't accept free products or payment for placement, and we say where something else is the better buy. Details of other products are from their makers and retailers unless we say we've used them. How we write these

The short version

True wind
The wind that's actually blowing across the water — what you'd feel standing still. Its direction is what the race committee, the forecast and the wind shifts are about.
Apparent wind
The wind you feel on a moving boat: the true wind plus the wind made by your own speed. It's what your sails, telltales and stay yarns respond to.
Upwind
The apparent wind is stronger and further forward than the true wind. Downwind it's weaker.
Why it matters
A gust swings the apparent wind aft and a lull swings it forward — so your telltales move without the wind shifting at all. Trim and steer to the apparent wind; decide when to tack from the true wind.

Two winds

Stand on the dock and the wind you feel is the true wind: the air moving over the water. Now ride a bicycle on a still day and you feel a breeze in your face that isn't there for anyone standing by the road — your own speed makes it. A sailboat feels both at once, added together. That combination is the apparent wind, and it's the only wind your sails ever see.

Sailors talk about both, often without saying which. The race committee sets the course to the true wind; a forecast, a wind shift and a compass heading are all about the true wind. Your telltales, the yarns on your shrouds, your masthead wind indicator and the feel on your cheek are all about the apparent wind.

How the apparent wind is made

Your boat's speed makes a wind blowing from dead ahead, as strong as the boat is fast. Add it to the true wind — head to tail, the way you'd add two arrows — and the result is the apparent wind.

True wind plus boat speed makes the apparent wind A boat sails up the page close-hauled. The true wind, 10 knots, comes from 45 degrees off the starboard bow. The boat's own speed, 6 knots, adds a wind from dead ahead. Added together they make the apparent wind: about 15 knots from 28 degrees off the bow — stronger and further forward than the true wind. True wind 10 kt, 45° Apparent wind ~15 kt, 28° Boat speed 6 kt (a wind from dead ahead) The apparent wind is what your sails, telltales and stay yarns feel.
Upwind, the wind you feel is stronger and further forward than the wind that's actually blowing.

In the example, a boat beating at 6 knots in 10 knots of true wind sails 45° off the true wind but feels about 15 knots coming from only 28° off the bow. That's why upwind always feels windier than it is, and why the sails are sheeted in tight even though the true wind is well off the bow.

On every point of sail

Point of sailTrue windBoat speedApparent wind
Beat10 kt at 45°6 ktabout 15 kt at 28°
Beam reach10 kt at 90°6.5 ktabout 12 kt at 57°
Broad reach10 kt at 135°6 ktabout 7 kt at 99°
Run10 kt at 180°5 kt5 kt at 180°

Angles are measured from the bow. The boat speeds are illustrative; the pattern is what matters.

Two things follow. Upwind feels much windier than downwind — the same 10 knots feels like 15 on the beat and 5 on the run, which is why a breeze that seemed gentle on the run is suddenly a handful when you round the leeward mark. And the faster the boat, the further forward the apparent wind, which is why fast boats sail downwind with their sails pulled in and the wind apparently on the beam.

Puffs and lulls move the apparent wind

This is where apparent wind stops being theory. When a puff hits, the true wind gets stronger — but the boat hasn't sped up yet. For a moment the true wind outweighs the boat's speed, so the apparent wind swings aft and strengthens. In the example, a puff from 10 to 14 knots moves the apparent wind from 28° to about 31° before the boat accelerates.

A lull does the opposite: the true wind drops, the boat is still moving, and the apparent wind swings forward. Your jib's windward telltales lift as if you'd been headed.

Neither is a wind shift. The true wind's direction hasn't changed at all — only its strength. That's the trap: a lull looks exactly like a header on the telltales, and a sailor who tacks on it has just tacked on nothing.

What it means for telltales and stay yarns

Every telltale on the boat shows the apparent wind. The ones on the sails show how that air flows over the sail (see how to use telltales); the yarns tied to the shrouds and stays show the apparent wind's direction directly, before it reaches the sail. Watching them is fast and instinctive, and on a small boat it's often the best steering guide you have — but remember what they're measuring:

What it means for trim

You trim to the apparent wind, always — it's the only wind the sails feel. In practice:

What it means for steering and tacking

The rule of thumb that falls out of all this: steer and trim to the apparent wind; make tactical decisions from the true wind.

Doing it with Sail Tactician

Sail Tactician works in true wind. Use the telltales and stay yarns to steer, and the app to decide: they are the two halves of the rule above.

Questions

What is the difference between true wind and apparent wind?

True wind is the wind actually blowing across the water. Apparent wind is what you feel on a moving boat: the true wind combined with the wind created by your own speed. Your sails and telltales respond to the apparent wind.

Why does sailing upwind feel windier than downwind?

Because upwind your boat speed adds to the true wind, so the apparent wind is stronger; downwind it subtracts. In 10 knots of true wind, a boat beating at 6 knots feels about 15 knots, and running at 5 knots feels only 5.

Do telltales show true or apparent wind?

Apparent wind — every telltale and wind indicator on a moving boat does. That's why they move with puffs and lulls as well as with real wind shifts.

Should I tack when my telltales show a header?

Only if it's a real shift in the true wind. A lull swings the apparent wind forward and looks like a header on the telltales, but the true wind hasn't changed direction. Check your compass heading against your baseline before tacking.

Sources

The apparent-wind figures are worked out from the vector sum of the true wind and the boat's speed; the boat speeds are illustrative. Sail Tactician behavior from the in-app User Guide, version 3.2.

What changed

  • First published.

Put a racing instrument on your wrist.

Start line, wind shifts and VMG at a glance, and a coach in your pocket afterwards. Free to download for Apple Watch and iPhone, with the full debrief on your first five races.

Download on the App Store